+- Be Right Back, Uninstalling (https://www.brbuninstalling.com)
+-- Forum: Technology (https://www.brbuninstalling.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=51)
+--- Forum: Computers (https://www.brbuninstalling.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=69)
+--- Thread: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? (/showthread.php?tid=9375)
Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - fyre - 02-09-2009
I'd like to get something under for $100, cheaper is better. Don't necessarily need a lot of room, 250GB should be enough, but less would be ok if it was cheap enough. Any ideas?
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - Ianki - 02-09-2009
firewire? really?
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - fyre - 02-09-2009
(02-09-2009, 08:05 PM)Ianki link Wrote: firewire? really?
Yeah, for a Final Cut Pro class. The instructor said Firewire is faster than USB with Macs.
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - Mission Difficult - 02-09-2009
I like G-Technology stuff. I think the cheapest one they have though is 160GB for $120USD. Give 'em a look.
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - Ianki - 02-09-2009
(02-09-2009, 08:09 PM)fyre link Wrote: [quote author=Ianki link=topic=2305.msg65811#msg65811 date=1234227923]
firewire? really?
Yeah, for a Final Cut Pro class. The instructor said Firewire is faster than USB with Macs.
[/quote]
Do macs not use usb 2, or is firewire just better on macs?
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - Mission Difficult - 02-09-2009
They have USB2, but Firewire has better sustained throughput. Firewire devices use a peer to peer architecture whereas USB is master-slave. So for Firewire the devices can negotiate bus conflicts and decide which device to control the data transfer. For USB, the host handles all arbitrary functions which means more overhead and slower data transfer control.
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - Blues - 02-10-2009
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822101095
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - ainmosni - 02-10-2009
(02-09-2009, 09:00 PM)Mission Difficult link Wrote: They have USB2, but Firewire has better sustained throughput. Firewire devices use a peer to peer architecture whereas USB is master-slave. So for Firewire the devices can negotiate bus conflicts and decide which device to control the data transfer. For USB, the host handles all arbitrary functions which means more overhead and slower data transfer control.
Exactly this. This isn't apple specific though, this goes for all OSes. Firewire is a nice protocol for external storage... always has been. It's just a little more expensive because it needs controllers in all peripherals. The 'max speed' in USB specs is always burst speed while in firewire it's 'sustained' speed. But then again Mission already said that.
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - fyre - 02-10-2009
(02-10-2009, 07:54 AM)Blues link Wrote: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822101095
I dunno if I want to buy a HD without any reviews. :-\
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - Blues - 02-10-2009
(02-10-2009, 09:01 AM)fyre link Wrote: [quote author=Blues link=topic=2305.msg65880#msg65880 date=1234270483]
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822101095
I dunno if I want to buy a HD without any reviews. :-\
[/quote]
Would you rather a hard drive with 500 reviews, 499 of which are idiots going "OMG THIS HARD DRIVE IS BIG I LIKE IT +" or "OMG I BOUGHT THIS AND THE FIREWIRE PLUG DOESN'T FIT IN MY USB PORT -"?
You've got a month to return it to newegg and a year warranty. Of course you can always spend 100$ more for a namebrand.
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - copulatingduck - 02-10-2009
This one by them has reviews: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16822101094
I can't imagine that the 500GB is that different from the 1TB model in terms of quality.
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - IdiotWithGuns - 02-10-2009
seems kind of pricey to me. why not buy an enclosure and a drive seperately?
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - fyre - 02-10-2009
(02-10-2009, 12:03 PM)IdiotWithGuns link Wrote: seems kind of pricey to me. why not buy an enclosure and a drive seperately?
I don't know how to do that...
Re: Need an External HD with Firewire - Recommendations? - Blues - 02-10-2009
(02-10-2009, 12:03 PM)IdiotWithGuns link Wrote: seems kind of pricey to me. why not buy an enclosure and a drive seperately?Price of 500GB external - 104$ free shipping
Price of 500GB internal - 65$ with 5$ shipping
Price of reliable enclosure that won't overheat your drive with firewire support - 30$ - 60$ + 5$ shipping
Wat?