+- Be Right Back, Uninstalling (https://www.brbuninstalling.com)
+-- Forum: Technology (https://www.brbuninstalling.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=51)
+--- Forum: Computers (https://www.brbuninstalling.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=69)
+--- Thread: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 (/showthread.php?tid=9587)
Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - cannedpeahes - 03-19-2009
I recently bought a VGA-to-composite adapter for my Dell M1530 laptop so I could connect it to an old RCA-made tube TV that I just bought at a steal from a friend. All I was looking to do was have an HTPC so I could watch some DVDs, maybe play a little (crackly, low-quality) music.
I plugged in the RCA adapter and all the composite cables to both the TV and laptop, but there was no result, even when I pressed Fn+F8 (Dell's "CRT/LCD" switch). I went into the nVidia Control Panel (the machine runs on an 8600M) and set it up for multiple displays using Dualview, even making the primary monitor the old TV. I set the resolution of the TV-Out to 640x480 (the closest a computer can come to NTSC, I think) and the refresh rate to 60Hz.
Still, the only effect it had was to produce a little crackly noise and a slight flicker on the TV, but it went right back to a black screen.
Any ideas?
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - Fail Medic - 03-19-2009
Beyond "Force TV" detect, like on an ATI card, I wouldn't know. I can do S-video off my desktop's card and convert that to composite, but I didn't know you could do VGA to composite. I do have my laptop connected to my TV in my room, but it has a built-in VGA port
. sry peaches
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - Mission Difficult - 03-19-2009
From what I can tell that model has an S-video out so try that. If the tv doesn't have an S-video input you can always get an s to composite adapter.
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - cannedpeahes - 03-20-2009
I should probably try S-to-composite if I can get my hands on one. It's just a shame I bought this adapter first.
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - HeK - 03-20-2009
You do understand that VGA is completely different from Component video, right?
VGA uses five pairs and produces 'RGB' video, while component is three-pair 'colour difference' video.
You will need either:
a) A video card that can produce component video
b) A TV that can process VGA video
c) A VGA to colour difference scan converter.
(Minor nit-picking: Component is the three RCA connectors, red, green, blue. Composite is the single yellow video cable).
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - cannedpeahes - 03-22-2009
(03-20-2009, 05:55 PM)HeK link Wrote: You do understand that VGA is completely different from Component video, right?
VGA uses five pairs and produces 'RGB' video, while component is three-pair 'colour difference' video.
You will need either:
a) A video card that can produce component video
b) A TV that can process VGA video
c) A VGA to colour difference scan converter.
(Minor nit-picking: Component is the three RCA connectors, red, green, blue. Composite is the single yellow video cable).
Yeah. That's the one, composite. Sorry. Little yellow cable.
I can't see why such things as VGA-to-composite would exist if they don't... work?
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - HeK - 03-22-2009
No idea. Likely the same reason a USB 'splitter' (not hub) exists.
I know Component to VGA works on most projectors, but that's from a DVD/Xbox into a projector/TV with VGA inputs.
But doesn't work the other-way around.
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - Ceceil Felias - 03-27-2009
There'd have to be some internal logic and power for a VGA signal to be converted to a basic composite signal.
Also, regarding VGA/component comparisons, VGA D-SUB connections are still analog, whereas component is digital. A better comparison would be DVI/component, and even then you'd have to configure the device outputting the data to use an RGB set instead of a Cr/Cb/Y set. xD
If your laptop has an S-Video output, though, a converter on that would work MUCH better. S-Video in itself is just a composite cable with two seperate wires to send the analog data. xD An adapter for that is pretty simple.
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - HeK - 03-28-2009
Not to be a jerk Ceceil, but most of your post is incorrect.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Component_video
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Composite_video
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S-Video
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - Mission Difficult - 03-28-2009
To her credit there is a digital component video that uses the YCbCr colorsapce i believe she was referring to, but it's still way less common than analog component video.
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - HeK - 03-28-2009
(03-28-2009, 11:06 AM)Mission Difficult link Wrote: To her credit there is a digital component video that uses the YCbCr colorsapce i believe she was referring to, but it's still way less common than analog component video.In that case, I retract my previous statement.
However, doesn't the YCbCr colour space apply mainly to digital video encoding? Use of chroma sub-sampling to produce smaller files?
Whereas physical component connections are still an analog transmission, oppose to a binary signaled transmission like the common 2-bit 0,-5,+5 scheme found in digital-coaxial audio?
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - Ceceil Felias - 03-29-2009
Oh, component video is mainly analog? My bad.
Still, on the other part of my post, it's pretty clear even on Wikipedia that S-video is the same signals as Composite on seperate wires. :p
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - HeK - 03-29-2009
Pretty much. The luminance and chrominance signals are separated on S-video.
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - cannedpeahes - 04-01-2009
It's Greek to me.
What I did gather is that S-video is composite, which is good enough for me. And I think I may have understood the words luminance and chrominance.
Re: Having Trouble with VGA-to-RCA on my Dell M1530 - at0m - 04-06-2009
(03-28-2009, 12:47 PM)HeK link Wrote: However, doesn't the YCbCr colour space apply mainly to digital video encoding? Use of chroma sub-sampling to produce smaller files?I know that Y'CbCr is highly noise-tolerant, especially on the Chroma signals. I'm not sure about it being used in digital video encoding, but I can definitely see being able to quantize those signals at a lower bitrate than you normally would use (which would allow for smaller filesize), since you can't really see the difference.
I also remember something about Y'CbCr and YPbPr being different, but I think its mainly that Y'CbCr is used to refer to a digital signal and YPbPr to an analog one encoded the same way.
<3 DSP
</random technical rant>